What can we learn about evidence-based practice when we read about Tecumseh?

The October 2013 issue of Fife & Drum, the the newsletter of The Friends of Fort York and Garrison Common, can be accessed here:

fife-and-drum-oct-2013

When I first encountered the newsletter, I printed it out and found that the font – which appears to be 10-point Adobe Caslon Pro – was too small for me to read at any length.

However, I read enough of the first article in the newsletter to realize at once that the content is of interest.

I used Adobe Acrobat Pro to convert the article to a larger font in Microsoft Word, and at that point read the beginning of the newsletter more closely.

Popular Culture’s Hold on Tecumseh

The lead article, by Kyle Carsten Wyatt, is entitled: “Popular Culture’s Hold on Tecumseh.”

Kyle Wyatt, as the article notes, is the managing editor of The Walrus magazine, and a Friends of Fort York board member. He holds a Ph.D. in American and Indigenous literatures from the University of Toronto.

An aerial view of Fort York looking east shows the substantial progress on the Visitor Centre that’s been made over the summer. Photo by Danny Williams. Source: October 2013 Fife & Drum newsletter published by The Friends of Fort York and Garrison Common

I recall reading with interest Wyatt’s article about ‘garrison and condominium mentalities’ in the May 2010 issue of The Walrus, a magazine that takes an evidence-based approach to reporting about many topics – including how best to address issues such as addiction, by way of example, as I’ve discussed in recent posts.

Wyatt’s article about Tecumseh, which you can access at the link at the beginning of this post, begins with the following opening paragraphs:

  • Earlier this year, the Montreal-based CSL Group completed Tecumseh – a 228.5-metre, 71,405-tonne Trillium-class self-unloader. The cargo ship, among the most advanced in the world, enters service for CSL’s Americas division just in time for the two hundredth anniversary of the Battle of the Thames, and the death of its famed namesake.
  • Tecumseh joins a centuries’ long tradition of letters, song, and material culture that purports to honour the nineteenth-century Shawnee leader while simultaneously evacuating his name of meaningful historical significance or culturally specific agency. This tradition operates like an empty ship: a vessel that governments and private concerns, in Canada and the United States, can fill at their discretion with partisan interpretations of the past and propaganda for the present. The Shawnee Confederacy and Tecumseh’s role in the War of 1812 become mere containers, the contents of which are determined by colonial powers.

[End of excerpt – As a complement to the recent photo (above) click here to view an archival photo of Fort York looking west prior to the condo development.]

This is a valuable article and well worth reading.

Evidence-based practice as viewed by a professional historian

The article brings to mind the concept of evidence-based practice.

A professional historian, if I understand correctly, deals with evidence in the form of archival records and the like.

There’s a truism, as I’ve discussed in previous posts, that war is politics – which entails the systematic application of instrumental reason – by other means. Conversely, there’s a truism that politics is war – which entails the management of organized violence – by other means.

The case of Veit Harlan – among many others – underlines the fact that history can be readily twisted and distorted to serve political ends including the conduct of genocide.

From a political perspective, evidence as found in archives isn’t necessarily of much interest.

From a political perspective, accurate and balanced information can, indeed, stand as a detriment to effective communication.

A reliance on purportedly scientific reports prepared by a fake scientist, and the enactment of tight controls over discussion and dissemination of scientific evidence, as highlighted in an earlier blog post, serve as illustrations of useful strategies in this regard.

A corollary to the article by Kyle Wyatt, regarding popular culture and Tecumseh, is that it follows that in order to create a politically useful myth about a historical figure, the less you let the historical facts get in the way, the more compelling your story will be.

The converse is also true: If the event you have an interest in a historical figure about whom no mythology has been constructed – as is true, by way of example, of Colonel Samuel Smith – you can have a great time imagining the life of that person by referring to the historical evidence related to the times in which he or she lived.

From the viewpoint of a professional politician the evidence that matters, from what I can gather, is the evidence that helps a person attain specified political objectives.

This is evidence based upon a study of tactics and strategies that lead to electoral success, or that lead to the enactment of policies in alignment with specified ideologies, in specified circumstances.

Evidence-based practice as it pertains to usability

I will conclude with a comment about readability – or usability – with reference to the experience of the reader, the end-user of a published text.

The above-noted newsletter is published, from what I can gather, in a text that is set in 10-point Adobe Caslon Pro.

Given the size of the font, a question arises: How many people will actually read this first-rate content?

Some usability research may be helpful.

The feedback that I’m pleased to share regarding this topic is from a person who is highly impressed and inspired by Fort York, as I’ve mentioned in previous posts.

The communications strategy would be more effective, in my view, if the font size were to be increased to about 11.5 or 12 points.

Part of the readership demographic for such a newsletter involves people over fifty who are keen about history but not so keen – for reasons related to a decrease in visual acuity as the years go by – about tiny print.

To arrive at a larger font, and maybe slightly increase the line spacing for enhanced readability, you’d need to reduce the length of articles in such a newsletter – possibly turning some of them into blurbs instead of full-length overviews.

The result would be a newsletter of the same length – that is, ten pages – that would likely reach a wider audience of keen readers.

Updates

The discussion brings to mind a subsequent post, entitled:

Memories are malleable – capable of being stretched or bent into different shapes

A Feb. 10, 2016 Guardian article is entitled: “Opinion vs facts: why do celebrities so often get it wrong? Celebrities often make wildly inaccurate claims and comments to millions of people. But the workings of our minds mean we’re all prone to such behaviour.”

A Jan. 23, 2017 article at earlycanadianhistory.ca is entitled: “Anishinaabeg in the War of 1812: More than Tecumseh and his Indians.”

 

0 replies

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Enter Captcha Here : *

Reload Image